Keeping it Brief: The Best Men’s Underwear, as Tested By Our Editors

Keep your boys high and tight...but not *that* tight.

We may earn an affiliate commission when you click on one of our links to sites like Amazon and other major retailers.  Why trust us?

Best Underwear For Men 2024

We’re clearly not models around here, but if it’s one thing we know about it’s testing products and pretty much only recommending things we love (and use).  This time around we’re totally ass-out and coming up with a short list of our favorite underwear we sport on the regular. 

When the waistband is busted or your name is still written on the back tag it’s probably time for an upgrade.  Toss out those dull tighty whities and dare to go bold in stripes or a variety of floral patterns.  Relax, it’s just underwear so you can handle it.  Odd science has proven that women and men judge your sexy-factor by the style of underwear you sport.  Gotta go with boxers?  Do it, just take a little risk and make sure they’re not too “boxy.”  Whether you’re a briefs guy or can’t get out of the boxer-briefs vacuum since 1998, men’s underwear has come a long way.

We’ve Google’d so many different lists and, lately, we’ve noticed that everyone is giving you like 20 pairs of underwear to choose from?  How is that helpful?!  So, we’re keeping it short and providing you a list of the best picks based on what some of the editors here at Brostrick actually wear.  Here’s the criteria when it comes to how we tested and chose the best.

BROSTRICK'S TESTING CRITERIA

COMFORT

How comfy is it to actually wear these undies? Truly comfortable underwear should feel snug but not too tight, and it should not chafe or irritate your skin. Our testing for comfort involved wearing the underwear for extended periods to see how it feels throughout the day.

THE FIT

We feel like it should fit well and provide adequate support without feeling constricting. It should stay in place without riding up or slipping down, especially when you’re walking, running, at the gym.

MATERIAL

The material of the underwear is obviously vital for ultimate comfort and overall performance. Breathable fabrics like cotton, modal, or bamboo are often preferred as they help wick away moisture and keep you cool and dry in all the right places. Our testing involved assessing how well the material breathes and how it feels against our skin.

DURABILITY

We feel that good underwear should be able to withstand regular wear and washing without losing its shape or developing holes. Our testing for durability involved washing the underwear multiple times and checking for any signs of wear and tear like stretching, loose threads, waistband ripples, etc.

Outside of our top 4 testing criteria, we also looked at areas we’ve deemed important like:

Moisture-Wicking: Moisture-wicking properties are essential for keeping you dry and comfortable, especially during physical activities like going on runs, hitting the gym, etc. Testing involved assessing how well the underwear absorbs and evaporates moisture.

Odor Control: Good underwear should also have odor-resistant properties to keep you feeling fresh throughout the day. Testing involved wearing the underwear for an extended period (like the whole day) and evaluating whether it retains odors.

Seams and Stitching: Smooth seams and sturdy stitching are important for preventing irritation and ensuring the underwear maintains its shape. Testing involved inspecting the seams and stitching for any signs of weakness or roughness over a period of time, including after washing.

Waistband: The waistband should be comfortable and secure without digging into your skin or rolling down. Testing involved assessing how well the waistband held up throughout the day.

OUR BEST UNDERWEAR WINNERS

Saxx Droptemp Cooling Briefs

Saxx Underwear Camo

PROS
CONS

Saxx may be the underwear brand you haven’t heard of, but one that you need to know about.  Famous for their “ball pouch” these odor-controlled, temp dropping, moisture-wicking briefs feel oh-so buttery soft, keeps your boys in place, and sits nicely at your waist without squeezing too tight, which kind of keeps your ever-growing muffin top in place without spilling over (in most cases).  

If you’re a hot sleeper or just a big sweater during the day, these will probably be your best bet.  Personally, I even wore mine during a 2.5 mile outdoor run during the day and while I was certainly a sweaty mess it kept my boys from bouncing around and kept me pretty dry.  A total plus if you’re a swamp-ass kinda guy.  No judgement.

SPECS:

Tommy John Cool Cotton Briefs

Tommy John Cool Briefs For Men

PROS
CONS

Saxx may be the underwear brand you haven’t heard of, but one that you need to know about.  Famous for their “ball pouch” these odor-controlled, temp dropping, moisture-wicking briefs feel oh-so buttery soft, keeps your boys in place, and sits nicely at your waist without squeezing too tight, which kind of keeps your ever-growing muffin top in place without spilling over (in most cases).  

If you’re a hot sleeper or just a big sweater during the day, these will probably be your best bet.  Personally, I even wore mine during a 2.5 mile outdoor run during the day and while I was certainly a sweaty mess it kept my boys from bouncing around and kept me pretty dry.  A total plus if you’re a swamp-ass kinda guy.  No judgement.

SPECS:

Tommy Bahama Knit Boxers (2)

Tommy Bahama Knit Boxers

PROS
CONS

Saxx may be the underwear brand you haven’t heard of, but one that you need to know about.  Famous for their “ball pouch” these odor-controlled, temp dropping, moisture-wicking briefs feel oh-so buttery soft, keeps your boys in place, and sits nicely at your waist without squeezing too tight, which kind of keeps your ever-growing muffin top in place without spilling over (in most cases).  

If you’re a hot sleeper or just a big sweater during the day, these will probably be your best bet.  Personally, I even wore mine during a 2.5 mile outdoor run during the day and while I was certainly a sweaty mess it kept my boys from bouncing around and kept me pretty dry.  A total plus if you’re a swamp-ass kinda guy.  No judgement.

SPECS:

MEET THE EDITOR