Skip to content 
Start here
Nobody returns underwear because the fabric was disappointing. They stop wearing a pair because it rides up and they chafe, or because they're damp all afternoon, or because the waistband has been digging a line into them since ten in the morning.
So this guide is built around those failures rather than around brands. Pick the thing that keeps happening to you and we'll tell you what causes it and which pairs fix it. Every one of them has a cause you can name, and none of them is your size.
The other thing we've done is stop using measurements. Every pair below is described against a standard boxer brief, because that's the cut you've already owned. Shorter leg, longer leg, no leg at all. Where a brand publishes a real inseam it's at the bottom of the card.
Where this guide landed
Start with the problem
Which of these keeps happening to you
Not body types and not brands. Pick the thing that actually goes wrong and we'll tell you what causes it and which pairs fix it.
5 problems cover almost everybody
Every one has a cause you can name and a fix you can buy. Start with whichever one you've been putting up with.
The leg walks up and the skin starts rubbing
You put them on, they sit right, and an hour later the leg has crawled up and bunched at the top of your thigh. Then skin meets skin and the day gets long. This is the single most common complaint about underwear and it isn't your size.
Two things cause it. The leg is too short, so there's nothing holding it down, and the leg opening has no grip. Go longer, and look for a bonded or elasticated leg band rather than a raw hem. Or go the other way entirely and wear a brief, where there's no leg to ride up in the first place.
The words on the package
What the styles actually mean
Brief, trunk, boxer brief, long boxer brief and loose boxer, in plain words: what each one does to the leg, and who it's for.
Boxer brief
The default, and the one to measure against
What it does to the leg
A fitted leg that runs partway down the thigh, usually somewhere around six inches. Enough leg to stop skin rubbing on skin, not so much that it bunches behind the knee.
Who it suits
Almost everyone. If you have no strong opinion, this is the cut you already own and the one that solves the most problems at once.
Worth knowing
This is the reference length on this page. When we say a pair is shorter or longer, this is what we're measuring it against.
The measuring stick
How much leg each one gives you
One line each, from no leg at all to the longest here. The standard boxer brief length is marked, and everything to the left of it covers less of your thigh.
Coverage comes from the cut rather than from a number, because almost no brand publishes an inseam. The two that do have it printed on their cards.
The shortlist
Thirteen pairs, grouped by the job
Everything here is in stock and currently made. Four of them link through Amazon, where the price moves daily and by size, so those cards send you to check rather than printing a number that would be wrong by next week.
The everyday ones
The pairs to buy six of. These are the ones that solve the ordinary problems, feel good from the first wear, and are still being made in the same version next year so you can replace them without starting again.
The pouch everyone else copied
SAXX Vibe Boxer Brief
SAXX built their whole company on one idea: a mesh panel sewn in as a separate pocket so nothing sticks to anything. It worked well enough that half the brands on this page now sell their own version of it, and SAXX still does it best.
The Vibe is the everyday one rather than the performance one. It's soft, it has a wide waistband that doesn't roll, and the leg has a proper grip so it stays where you put it. If you're buying your first pouch pair, buy this one.
The pouch takes up room that a flat-front pair doesn't, so a lot of guys find their usual size feels tight the first time. If you're on the line between two, take the larger one.
You adjust yourself all day and you'd like to stop.
You want the cheapest thing that works. This isn't it, and the value is real but it isn't cheap.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
The softest thing here
MeUndies Boxer Brief with Fly
MicroModal is the reason people become irrational about MeUndies. It's noticeably softer than cotton, it dries much faster, and the difference is obvious within about ten seconds of putting a pair on.
The cut is a plain, correct boxer brief with a contoured front and a wide band. Nothing clever, which is the point. This is the pair to buy if you want to solve underwear once and think about something else.
MeUndies pushes a subscription hard and you can buy single pairs without it. The membership is worth it only if you actually intend to buy a pair every month, which almost nobody does.
Softness is the thing you care about most.
You want performance fabric for the gym. Modal is lovely and it isn't that.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
The best waistband on the page
Mack Weldon AIRKNITx Trunk
If your complaint is the waistband, this is the answer. Mack Weldon's band is wide, bonded rather than sewn, and it stays flat instead of folding over on itself. It's the detail they get most obviously right.
It's a trunk, so the leg stops just below the crotch. That's cooler and less bulky under trousers, and it's the cut to pick if a full boxer brief has always felt like a lot of fabric to you.
The shorter leg means less holding it down, so if your actual problem is riding up, a trunk will make it worse rather than better. Go the other way and buy more leg.
Waistbands are your problem, or you run hot under trousers.
You chafe. This is the shortest leg here and it won't help.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
The one that survives a workday
Duluth Trading Buck Naked Boxer Brief
Duluth sell these to people who spend the day on their feet, and it shows. The nylon and spandex knit dries faster than anything else here at the price, it doesn't hold shape memory in the wrong places, and it survives a lot of washing.
They're also the cheapest thing on this page that's genuinely good rather than adequate. Under twenty five dollars for a pair that does the job of ones costing half again as much.
Two of those three hold up completely. The nylon does hang onto smell more than modal or merino does over a long day, so if odor is your specific worry the merino pair further down is the honest recommendation.
You're on your feet all day and you want value.
You want something that feels soft and luxurious. This feels technical, on purpose.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
Bamboo, and cooler than it sounds
Boody Everyday Boxer Brief
Bamboo viscose sits somewhere between cotton and modal: softer than cotton, cooler against the skin, and much better at moving moisture. Boody have built a whole range on it and this is the plainest thing they make.
The waistband is soft and wide rather than structured, which some people love and some find too relaxed. Worth knowing which of those you are before you order six.
This is a flat-front cut with no separate pocket. If bunching is the problem you're trying to solve, this pair doesn't solve it and two of the ones above do.
You want something soft and cool and you don't care about a pouch.
You want structure. These are deliberately relaxed everywhere.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
For heat, sweat and long days
When the problem is moisture rather than fit. Every pair here is built to move sweat off your skin instead of holding it there, and one of them refuses to smell no matter what you do to it.
Cotton that behaves like it should not
SAXX DropTemp Cooling Boxer Brief
The trick here is a cooling treatment worked into a cotton knit, so you get the hand feel of cotton without the usual penalty of it holding sweat all day. It genuinely runs cooler than a plain cotton pair.
It's a three pack, which is the sensible way to buy underwear anyway, and it has the same BallPark pouch as the Vibe. If you like cotton and hate what cotton does in summer, this is the pair that fixes it.
Cooling cotton is cooler than normal cotton. It isn't nylon and it isn't merino, and on a genuinely hot day the Under Armour or the Smartwool below will out-dry it. This is for people who want cotton to be less of a problem, not for people who've given up on it.
You love how cotton feels and hate how it performs.
You want the driest possible option. That's further down this section.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
The gym default, for good reason
Under Armour Tech Boxerjock
This is the pair most men who train already own, and it earns that. The knit is thin, it moves sweat off you fast, and the leg is long enough at six inches to stop the chafing that shorter cuts cause on a run.
It's also one of very few pairs on this page where the brand actually prints the inseam on the label, which is why we can tell you exactly how much leg you're getting rather than guessing.
That's the standard boxer brief length and it's the one that stops skin touching skin for most builds. If you're tall, six inches on you sits where four inches sits on someone else, and you should be looking longer.
You train, you sweat, and you want the thing that already works for everybody.
You want it to feel nice sitting at a desk. It's built for movement.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
The one you take travelling
Smartwool Merino Boxer Brief
Merino is the only fiber on this page that actively resists odor rather than just moving moisture around, and the difference on a long trip isn't subtle. People wear these for days at a time, which sounds unpleasant and genuinely isn't.
It also works in both directions on temperature, so a merino pair is comfortable in heat and in cold. There's no other fabric here you can say that about.
Merino is the most delicate thing on this page. Cold wash, no fabric softener, and hang them to dry. Put a pair through a hot dryer and you'll be disappointed in a way that isn't the wool's fault.
You travel, or you want one pair that handles any weather.
You want to buy six and stop thinking. These are a specialist item at a specialist price.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
For one specific problem
Two pairs that exist to fix one thing each, and do it better than anything general-purpose. Buy them for the problem, not as your whole drawer.
Two pouches, not one
SHEATH 4.0 Dual Pouch Boxer Brief
Most pouch underwear gives you one pocket. SHEATH gives you two, separated by a panel, so nothing touches anything else. It sounds like a gimmick and it's the single most effective fix on this page if sticking and shifting is your actual complaint.
The modal knit is soft and dries quickly, the five inch leg is short enough not to bunch, and the price is the lowest of anything here that solves a real problem.
It feels strange at first and then it feels normal, and then everything else feels wrong. Give it a few wears before you decide, which isn't advice we'd give about any other pair here.
You're adjusting yourself constantly and a normal pouch hasn't fixed it.
You've never had that problem. You're buying engineering you don't need.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
Shaping, said plainly
SPANX Sculpt Boxer Brief
SPANX make compression underwear for men and they've stopped being coy about it. These hold you in through the middle, which smooths the line of a shirt and makes a fitted suit sit better. That's the entire job.
The cotton and spandex knit is more comfortable than the category deserves, and it's the pair to own for a wedding, an interview or anything else where you'd like the shirt to lie flat.
These are firm, and firm is the point. Most people find them excellent for an event and too much for a full working week. Buy one or two rather than a drawer.
You want a cleaner line under a fitted shirt on a specific occasion.
You want everyday comfort. There are nine better answers above.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
If you don't want a boxer brief
Briefs and loose boxers, which between them cover the two ends of the range. One has no leg to ride up at all and the other has no fit to speak of.
The brief that changed people's minds
Tommy John Cool Cotton Brief
Tommy John are the brand that made grown men reconsider briefs, and this is the one that does it. It's cut far less severely than the briefs you're picturing, the pouch is contoured properly, and there's no leg to ride up because there's no leg.
If chafing is your problem and you've been trying longer and longer boxer briefs to fix it, the other direction is worth a try. A brief solves the same problem by removing it.
At 86% Pima cotton and 14% spandex there's enough give that it moves with you rather than gripping, which is the failure mode of most briefs. It's still cotton, so it'll hold moisture the way cotton does.
Thigh chafing is your whole problem and you're ready to try the other answer.
You want the underwear line to disappear under thin trousers. A brief has an edge and it shows.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
The cheap way to try a brief
Calvin Klein Micro Stretch Brief
Before you spend thirty dollars finding out whether briefs suit you, spend a lot less finding out. Calvin Klein's micro stretch is soft, thin, and sold in threes, and it's the sensible way to run the experiment.
It's also just a good pair of underwear on its own terms. The waistband is the one everybody recognizes and the fabric is better than the price suggests.
Calvin Klein singles are priced oddly against the three packs, and the three pack is almost always the better deal by a wide margin. Check both before you add to cart.
You want to try briefs without committing.
You've already decided you want a pouch. This is a conventional front.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
For sleeping in, and not much else
Tommy Bahama Knit Boxers
A loose knit boxer does one thing better than everything else on this page: it lets air move. Nothing grips, nothing compresses, and on a hot night that's exactly what you want.
Tommy Bahama's are soft, well made and cut generously, and they're sold in twos. This is a lounging and sleeping product and it's an honest one.
That isn't a fault in the make, it's the shape. A loose boxer inside a fitted trouser has nowhere to go and it will gather. Wear them at home and wear something fitted out.
You sleep hot and you want something that breathes.
You need them to work under clothes. Almost anything else here is better for that.
The details, if you want them
What the brand publishes
Worth knowing, not worth agonizing over
What they're made of
Fabric matters most if you sweat and barely at all if you don't. Here's the short version, and then you can forget it.
Modal, soft and quick to dry4 of 13
Modal and micromodal are made from beech pulp and they're the softest thing here by a distance. They move moisture to the surface instead of soaking it up, so they dry fast. This is what most of the good everyday pairs are made of.
Viscose, soft and cool1 of 13
Viscose is a regenerated cellulose fiber, the same family as modal and as the bamboo viscose further down. It drapes softly, sits cool against the skin and moves moisture better than cotton does, which is why so much of the comfortable end of this category is made of it.
Nylon, built for sweat2 of 13
Nylon with a bit of spandex is the performance answer. It barely absorbs anything, it dries quickest of everything on this page, and it holds its shape through a lot of washing. The trade is that it can hang onto smell more than the others.
Merino, the odor answer1 of 13
The only fiber here that actively resists odor, which is why it's what people take travelling. It regulates temperature in both directions, so it works in heat and in cold. It's also the most expensive and the most delicate.
Bamboo viscose, cool and soft1 of 13
Bamboo viscose sits close to modal: very soft, cool against the skin, and better than cotton at moving moisture. It's the choice if softness matters more to you than out-and-out performance.
Cotton, and it holds moisture4 of 13
Comfortable, familiar, and the worst of these when you sweat. Cotton absorbs moisture and holds it against your skin, which is why a cotton pair feels damp for hours. Perfectly fine for a normal day at a desk, and the wrong choice for heat.
Side by side
Compare all thirteen
Tap a column heading to sort.
| Pair ▴▾ | Price ▴▾ | How much leg ▴▾ | The front ▴▾ | Fabric ▴▾ | Style ▴▾ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAXX Vibe Boxer Brief | $36 | Standard length | A built-in pouch | Viscose, soft and cool | Boxer brief |
| MeUndies Boxer Brief with Fly | $26 | Standard length | A contoured front | Modal, soft and quick to dry | Boxer brief |
| Mack Weldon AIRKNITx Trunk | $32 | Shorter leg | A contoured front | Modal, soft and quick to dry | Trunk |
| Duluth Trading Buck Naked Boxer Brief | $24.95 | Standard length | A contoured front | Nylon, built for sweat | Boxer brief |
| Boody Everyday Boxer Brief | $26 | Standard length | A flat front | Bamboo viscose, cool and soft | Boxer brief |
| SAXX DropTemp Cooling Boxer Brief | $89 | Standard length | A built-in pouch | Cotton, and it holds moisture | Boxer brief |
| Under Armour Tech Boxerjock | Varies | Standard length | A contoured front | Nylon, built for sweat | Boxer brief |
| Smartwool Merino Boxer Brief | Varies | Standard length | A flat front | Merino, the odor answer | Boxer brief |
| SHEATH 4.0 Dual Pouch Boxer Brief | $16.15 | Standard length | Two pouches, divided | Modal, soft and quick to dry | Boxer brief |
| SPANX Sculpt Boxer Brief | Varies | Standard length | A contoured front | Cotton, and it holds moisture | Boxer brief |
| Tommy John Cool Cotton Brief | $32 | No leg | A contoured front | Cotton, and it holds moisture | Brief |
| Calvin Klein Micro Stretch Brief | Varies | No leg | A contoured front | Modal, soft and quick to dry | Brief |
| Tommy Bahama Knit Boxers | $60 | Loose cut | A flat front | Cotton, and it holds moisture | Loose boxer |
A pouch is called out because it's the one construction detail that changes how a pair feels more than anything else on this table.
Getting it right
Five things that fix most underwear problems
None of this costs anything and all of it makes a bigger difference than spending more.
- Buy your real waist. Measure where the band will actually sit, not where your trousers sit. Buying too small is the most common mistake there is, and it causes both the digging and the riding up.
- Try one pair before you buy six. Cuts vary enormously between brands and a pouch takes about a week to feel normal. One pair for a week tells you everything a review can't.
- Wash cold and skip the dryer. Heat is what kills elastic, and a hot wash followed by a hot dryer will finish a good pair in a year. Cold water and a low tumble doubles their life.
- Own more pairs than you think you need. It sounds like the opposite of thrift and it isn't. More pairs in rotation means each one goes through the machine less often, and the whole drawer lasts longer.
- Match the fabric to your day. Cotton for a desk, nylon or modal if you move, merino if you're travelling. Getting this right fixes more than any amount of extra spending on the same old fabric.
Questions
Underwear, answered properly
How often should I actually replace underwear?
When the elastic goes, which is usually before anything else does. A waistband that's lost its snap, leg bands that no longer sit flat, or fabric that's gone thin and sheer at the seat are all signals. For most people that's somewhere between one and three years depending on how many pairs are in rotation and how hot you wash them. Owning more pairs genuinely makes each pair last longer, because none of them goes through the machine as often.
What's the difference between a trunk and a boxer brief?
Just the length of the leg. A trunk has the same shape through the seat and the front, then the leg stops shortly below the crotch. A boxer brief carries the leg partway down the thigh, usually around six inches. Trunks are cooler and less bulky under trousers. Boxer briefs are much better at stopping thighs rubbing, which is why they're the default.
Does a pouch actually do anything?
Yes, and it's the one real change in men's underwear in the last fifteen years. A traditional front is two flat panels sewn together, so there's nothing to sit in and everything shifts and sticks. A pouch is a separate three-dimensional pocket that keeps things forward and separated. Most people who try one stop buying flat-front underwear. A minority find it strange and never adjust, so it's worth trying one pair before buying six.
Which fabric is best if I sweat a lot?
Nylon dries fastest and merino handles odor best. Plain cotton is the worst option because it absorbs moisture and holds it against your skin for hours, which is exactly the feeling you're trying to avoid. Modal sits in the middle and is the best all-rounder: much better than cotton, softer than nylon, and quick to dry. If you sweat heavily and it's a daily problem, the fabric matters far more than the cut does.
Why do my boxer briefs ride up?
Almost always because the leg is too short for your build, or because the leg opening has no grip. A short leg has nothing holding it in place, so movement walks it up until it settles in the crease of your thigh. A hemmed raw edge does the same. What fixes it: more leg, and a proper bonded or elasticated leg band. Taller men should assume they need a longer inseam than the standard, because a six inch leg on a six foot four frame sits where a four inch leg sits on someone else.
Is merino wool worth the money for underwear?
For travel and for anything multi-day, genuinely yes. Merino is the only common fiber that actively resists odor rather than just moving moisture, and it regulates temperature in both directions so it works in heat and cold. For sitting at a desk five days a week it's hard to justify, because you're paying a large premium for a property you aren't using. Buy one or two pairs for trips rather than a drawer full.
What size should I buy?
Measure your waist where the band will actually sit, which is usually lower and larger than your trouser size suggests. Buying too small is the most common mistake and it's what causes the waistband to dig and the leg to ride. If you're between sizes and the pair has a pouch, size up, because the pouch takes room a flat front doesn't.
How should I wash them so they last?
Cold water, and either hang them or tumble on low. Heat is what kills elastic, and a hot wash followed by a hot dryer is the single fastest way to wear out a good pair. Skip fabric softener too, especially on anything technical or merino, because it coats the fibers and ruins the moisture handling you paid for.
Are multipacks worth it over single pairs?
Usually, and especially at the cheaper end, where the per-pair price on a three pack is often close to half the single price. The catch is that a multipack commits you to a cut you may not like. The sensible order is to buy one pair, wear it for a week, and then buy the multipack once you know.
Do I need underwear with a fly?
It's entirely preference and a surprising number of men never use one. A fly adds a seam and a small amount of bulk at the front. If you don't use it, a pair without one is slightly cleaner in construction. Nothing on this page hangs on the answer either way.
Method
How we put this together
Checked for stock, not assumed
Every pick was checked live for price and for how many sizes are actually available. One pair was on a clearance colorway with two sizes left and got swapped for the full-price version of the same thing.
Sorted by problem, not by brand
The groups are the job each pair does. That's the way underwear actually gets bought, and it's more useful than ranking thirteen things against each other when they're built for different days.
No prices we can't stand behind
Brand-site prices are the ones we read. The Amazon picks carry no price at all, because Amazon's changes by the day and by the size and a number here would be wrong within a week.
